Last Updated: by Kacey · This post may contain affiliate links · 59 Comments
My VERY popular roasted baby potatoes in a homemade mushroom sauce has gotten a makeover and it cannot get any better!
Christmas is almost here! I initially wanted to make today's roasted baby potatoes in a homemade mushroom sauce for my contribution to The Little Potato Company as a thank you for sharing their products with me. However, I decided to go with pan-fried fingerling potatoes with bacon. I must say, that recipe is doing amazing! Seems like everyone is enjoying the easy, but flavorful, dish. I could not enjoy the pan-fried fingerling potatoes,but I knew I wanted to revamp my popular mushroom pasta sauce recipe for myself.
The mushroom sauce worked outstandingly with these baby potatoes. I originally thought I put way too much liquid into this meal, but you would be surprised at how much the potatoes soak up, especially after they sit for some time. My husband is also a big rice lover, so he had no problem pouring any extra liquid on top of his rice. Personally, I love a bit of extra sauce when it comes to pasta or rice, so this roasted baby potatoes recipe worked perfectly for me. It is not a thick sauce, but I could see it working perfectly over mashed potatoes (or just about anything.)
It is a very simple dish to make, but a bit of work. UPDATE: Since revisiting this recipe I have made it so it is a one pan meal! The recipe tastes exactly like the original method, but reduces cooking time (and dishes!) drastically!
As always, the white wine is optional but I swear it makes this dish. I love it paired with mushrooms and it really brings through the earthiness of the mushrooms without masking flavors. UPDATE: When I revisited this recipe I was actually out of white wine. I used red wine instead and it was just as good, if not better! If alcohol isn't your thing, just use more broth!
📖 Recipe
Roasted Baby Potatoes in a Homemade Mushroom Sauce
Yield: 2
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 45 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour
Making this meal all in one pan saves time and dishes!
Ingredients
- 1.5 pounds baby OR Creamer potatoes, washed and left whole
- 2 large portobello mushrooms, halved and sliced ¼-1/2 inch thick
- 8 oz button mushrooms, sliced
- 3 garlic cloves, minced
- 2 tbsp. olive oil
- 3 tbsp. balsamic vinegar
- Salt and pepper
- ¼ tsp. red chili flakes
- ¼ tsp. ground thyme
Sauce
- ⅔ cup vegetable broth
- ½ cup heavy whipping cream
- ⅓ cup white OR red wine (can omit and use more broth)
- ¼ cup chives, chopped (about 30 grams or 1 oz)
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 425F.
- Place mushrooms, potatoes, garlic, olive oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, chili flakes, and thyme into a large mixing bowl. Toss until evenly coated. Pour into a large cast iron skillet and spread out evenly. Roast for 15 minutes. Toss and cook for another 15 minutes, or until potatoes are fork tender. Remove from oven and place pan over medium heat.
- Pour in wine and cook until dissipated, about 2-3 minutes. Pour in broth and cream. Sprinkle with half the chives. Bring to a boil and simmer for 5 minutes. Garnish with remaining chives and serve!
- Note: If you do not have a cast iron pan, just cook the mixture in an oven safe pan or baking sheet and then transfer to a stove-top frying or saute pan to finish the recipe off!
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 2Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving:Calories: 980Total Fat: 70gSaturated Fat: 47gTrans Fat: 1gUnsaturated Fat: 18gCholesterol: 67mgSodium: 681mgCarbohydrates: 75gFiber: 6gSugar: 11gProtein: 12g
I could eat this sauce all day, every day. I am sure my body would eventually hate all that cream, but it is just the perfect amount of richness. I could see this recipe working easily for vegans by subbing in the almond milk for the whipping cream. I may have to give that a go soon so Mr. TCW doesn't have to suffer through his lactose intolerance (though the amount of cream is so little it should not be too harsh.)
Instead of chives, fresh dill would work beautifully here. I was tempted to do fresh dill but I had recently made another loaf of my cheese and dill beerbread and thought it would be nice to change things up.
Love these roasted baby potatoes in a homemade mushroom sauce?! Try some of these recipes:
Portobello Mushroom Pasta with Cream Sauce
Pan-Fried Creamer Potatoes and Bacon with a Yogurt-Chive Sauce
« Toasted Coconut Butter
Crust-Less Lemon Cheesecake with Candied Cranberries »
Reader Interactions
Comments
Thalia @ butter and brioche
I often make roast veggies for dinner but never made a mushroom sauce to go along with them before. This is definitely something I will be trying.. thanks for the idea!
Reply
Kacey
No problem at all, Thalia 🙂
Reply
Claudia @ HomeMade with love
Wow this looks like pure perfection!! Can't wait to try it 🙂
Reply
Deb@ Cooking on the Front Burner
I love potatoes and mushrooms - great idea to pair them together!!
Reply
Kacey
I love both as well so it only made sense to throw them together!
Reply
Miranda @ Cookie Dough & Oven Mitt
Holy moly. This is the dish I need in my life. I love lots of sauce, especially if it's a mushroom sauce! How does one make roasted baby potatoes look so beautiful?
Reply
Kacey
By pairing them in lots of creamy mushroom sauce! 🙂
Reply
Nutmeg Nanny
Roasted potatoes are my favorite! I love that you threw them in a creamy mushroom sauce...yum!
Reply
Kacey
They are my husband's absolute favourite as well. Perfect side dish for just about anyone!
Reply
Laura @MotherWouldKnow
What a great way to go beyond the "plain potatoes" I'm often stuck on. Plus I love these baby potatoes, so tender and delicious!
See AlsoHomemade Spinach and Sausage LasagnaThe 5 Best Anti-Inflammatory Diet Foods - Beauty BitesGarlic Butter Steak and Potatoes SkilletInstant Pot Beef and Broccoli (Quick and Easy!) - Corrie CooksReply
Kacey
I love roasting them with butter, salt, and pepper, but sometimes we need to amp them up a bit!
Reply
Annie+@Maebells
This looks just incredible! I love any kind of "saucy" dishes so this is right up my alley!
Reply
Kacey
I have a weakness for sauces, too 🙂
Reply
Ashley
Is there anon dairy alternative to the creamer?
Reply
Kacey
Hi Ashley! To be honest, I have not tried any dairy alternatives. I'm always amazed at the products out there these days and feel you could throw a simple non-dairy milk here (like cashew perhaps,) and add in some nutritional yeast flakes to up the flavours. Sorry I am not more help.
Reply
Sara @ Bitz & Giggles
Oh my goodness. This looks amazing. Perfect side to any dish for sure. Pinning!
Reply
Kacey
Or a meal on their own (I totally ate them as is!)
Reply
Shannon @ Dinner from the Heart
Mushrooms in a cream sauce sounds divine and then to pair it with baby potatoes - oh, my mouth is watering! I'm sure roasting the portabellos brings out the best flavor in them. This looks so delicious. 🙂
Reply
Kacey
Roasting portobello mushrooms seems like my favourite method these days. The extra steps are worth it!
Reply
Jameson Fink
Never thought to put a mushroom sauce with potatoes; looks great. I wonder if you could adapt this to make a creamy potato/mushroom soup?
Reply
Kacey
That sounds like an awesome idea! I might have to whip something up (perfect timing since I have extra potatoes and mushrooms on hand.)
Reply
Kelley
Ohhh this looks amazing! I had mushroom cream sauce tonight with dinner. I will have to try your version!
Reply
Kacey
I don't think you could go wrong with having another night of mushroom cream sauce for dinner 🙂
Reply
Meg @ The Housewife in Training Files
OMG I can see why you would want to eat that sauce every day...I want to too!!
Reply
Kacey
Haha, I really wish I could eat it every day with no consequences!
Reply
Cate | Chez CateyLou
I could definitely make a meal out of these potatoes - they look amazing, and that mushroom sauce sounds incredible!
Reply
Kacey
See AlsoHealthy Sesame ChickenI actually ate them as a meal as opposed to servings them as a side 🙂
Reply
Diana
Omg looking at these pictures made me so hungry! This reminds me my university life I had roasted baby potatoes with mushrooms quite often, YUM! Plus you're an amazing photographer!
Reply
Kacey
Thank you so much! Your university life sounds much better than others when it comes to food 🙂
Reply
Heather
I just wanted to say that I made this tonight and it was absolutely amazing. The mushroom cream sauce was so delicious and flavorful, and added so much life to regular old roasted potatoes. I didn't have any of the big portobellos, so I just roasted up my baby bellas according to the recipe and combined with the white wine, potatoes and cream. Perfection.
Reply
Kacey
We absolutely love this dish and I am glad you loved it, too! Baby bellas sound great in this recipe and a lot less work. I may have to steal that idea 🙂
Reply
Sheril
Tried making this today !!! Yummmmm. My husband and I absolutely loved it!! Definitely bookmarking this recipe
Reply
Kacey
Yes! You have reminded me that I need to make these again!
Reply
Amanda
This dish tasted really good and I will try to find a way to make it again. But the recipe is not the best. First, the instructions for cooking the potatoes would leave you with extremely overlooked potatoes. I boiled for only 5 min and roasted for 10, but you could just eliminate the boiling and roast from 10-15 min. Second, there are WAY too many steps. The portobello mushroom, button mushroom, and potatoes each have a different and separate method of preparation. So many prep bowls! I really think this could be simplified, then this recipe would be a keeper. Very tasty.
Reply
Kacey
I am glad you liked the recipe! Sorry about any confusion, this is an old recipe and I definitely want to revisit it. I have learned to word instructions a bit more carefully 😉
Reply
Beth
This looks delicious and I can't wait to make it! I forgot broth!!! Anyone make it without the broth and just wine and cream??? I'm thinking it might thicken it a bit and maybe even cook some bacon first before the mushrooms eliminating the oil and using bacon grease instead...mmmmm mouth watering 😉
Reply
Kacey
Beth, your idea sounds delicious! I love cooking my potatoes in bacon fat! The broth is there to help thin the sauce out, but also cut the richness a bit. I don't see the harm in adding some starchy water to the sauce if you decide to boil the potatoes first.
Reply
Valerie
Hi Kacey,
The recipe looks delicious, I never roasted the mushrooms before!
I am not sure to find the brown portobello mushrooms where I live, never saw them. Do you think it is possible to roast white portobello mushrooms as well?Have a great day 🙂
Reply
Kacey
Oh, for sure! Use any mushrooms you like (I just like portobellos because they are gourmet without being too pricey!)
Reply
Vicky
is there something healthy that I can substitute the heavy whipping cream with?
Thanks!Reply
Kacey
Haha, yeah heavy cream is not the healthiest 🙂 You could use any type of cream or milk but remember that it will be thinner and cream has a pretty bold flavour compared to plain milk.
Reply
Kay
I went to cook this recipe but it didn't make any sense. Am I to bake the potatoes and mushrooms together? I would have thought that the sliced mushrooms would bake way before the potatoes? The instructions are not clear enough.
Reply
Kacey
Nope, the mushrooms and potatoes cook perfectly! You want to make sure you are using really small potatoes (I use The Little Potato Company's Baby Boomers.) Never had an issue with this recipe and have probably made it a dozen times! If you are concerned, you can always fry up the mushrooms while your potatoes cook.
Reply
Darla
So are the potatoes put into the pan with the mushrooms. etc? I am assuming they are, but they are not listed. Thanks.
Reply
Kacey
They sure are!
Reply
Natalie
Sounds delish! I'd like to try this soon. Do you think it would be ok to add baby carrots and cubes butternut squash (for both nutrition and pretty color) or would it be a hot mess?
Reply
Kacey
I always love adding more flavours! My only concern would be space. Think it would all fit into one pan? Maybe not a whole squash 🙂 But if you do add them, let me know how it goes!
Reply
Clyde
Modified this just a little and added leeks into the recipe instead of green onions or chives. I thought it add a more robust flavor.
Reply
Kacey
That sounds wonderful! I really need to use leeks more often.
Reply
Licia
I love potatoes and mushrooms and was excited to try the recipe last night. Had no wine in the house so I used Harveys Bristol Cream (Sherry). It was fabulous. Will try with white wine next time it is definitely a keeper!
Reply
Kacey
Yay! Thank you! I do find the wine makes a huge difference, but I am often out of it myself 🙂
Reply
Sharon
I have never committed on a recipe that I have tried online, but I had to for this one. This is so good that I had to comment. The sauce is soooogood that I could have just drank it. I cooked this with a leg of lamb and put that sauce over the cut pieces of lamb, and I was in heaven. This is more then a keeper it is going to be a tradition with my leg of lamb! I will have to try it with my ribeye steak or prime rib.
Now I did take a fork and poked holes in the potatoes before I made sauce. So that it would help them soak up the sauce and so the potatoes can release some of their starches to help thick up the sauce some.
Thank you for sharing your recipe with us!Reply
Kacey
Thank you so much!!! I agree, it is drink-worthy, lol. I also tend to use this sauce over various cuts of meat for my family because they love it so much!
Reply
Monique
This recipe is SO DELICIOUS! I left out the chives and it was still SO tasty, not to mention really easy as well. I left my button mushrooms whole because I love them that way. Thanks for the new dinner favourite!
Reply
Nadia Pella
This was a surprising recipe. I expected it to be good, but it was outstanding! I just finished it and am already thinking about when I am going to make it next. Great recipe!
Reply
Kellie
These potatoes are RIDICULOUS! So, so good! My husband made one request, double the sauce. But wow, these were easy and tasted amazing!
Reply
Kacey
It is comments like this that make me want to come back to blogging! Thank you!
Reply
Carol
I would use full fat coconut milk for the vegans, I think.
Reply
Kacey
I am curious to how that would go! Only one way to find out 🙂
Reply
