21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (2024)

As any kid will tell you, desserts are way tastier when they're made into a fun shape. As one of the easiest shapes to cut, hearts deserve a place in your cookie-cutter (or cake-pan) catalog all year long—not just on Valentine's Day. Is there any better way to show family and friends a little extra love than with a batch of heart cookies or a sweet slice of heart-shape cake? Of course, you can also treat yourself to these delightful desserts—we won't judge if you keep them all to yourself.

01of 21

Valentine's Day Heart Cookie Trio

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (1)

All it takes is one batch of sugar cookie dough to create three adorable cut-out treats: patchwork cookies covered in tiny hearts, others painted with Valentine's Day hues, and striped hearts that bring a touch of the geometric to all those curves. Finish off all three with a shimmery sprinkling of edible luster dust.

02of 21

Heart-Shape Chocolate Cream Puffs

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (2)

These heart-shape cream puffs are surprisingly simple: The only tool you need to make the festive shape is a cookie scoop! You can prepare these decadent puffs plain or with an infusion of chocolate; either way, they're filled with delicious pastry cream. It's perfectly acceptable to serve these unadorned, but we guarantee you won't regret adding a drizzle of hot fudge sauce.

03of 21

Conversation Heart Cut-Out Cookies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (3)

Baking a batch of heart-shape cookies is a thoughtful way to show friends and family you care—and adding personalized messages makes the gesture even sweeter. Use food coloring to dye the dough any color you desire, then use heart-shape cookie cutters and tiny stamps to create your own twist on conversation hearts.

How to Choose the Best Cookie Sheets for Baking Cookies

04of 21

Lavender-Lemon Pudding Cakes

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (4)

Of course, these fruity, floral cakes would taste the same if you made them as circles, but they're much cuter in heart-shape ramekins, don't you think? No matter which shape you choose, these creamy pudding cakes will delight your tastebuds with the sprinkle of rock crystal sugar and lavender on top.

05of 21

Swirled Meringue Hearts

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (5)

You don't need any special equipment to create these Valentine's Day desserts. Simply use a spoon to create the delicate heart shape. We flavored our meringues with raspberry and strawberry extracts but you can use any flavor you like.

Red Velvet Heart Cookies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (6)

You won't need frosting for these bright red velvet cookies—a dusting of powdered sugar on top is plenty. Create your own powdery patterns with a heart-shape stencil.

07of 21

Red Velvet Heart Cake

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (7)

From the moist red velvet cake to the fudgy chocolate frosting, everything about this heart cake is decadent. Customize every bite with stripes of raspberries, cherries, almonds, and pecans—a nod to everyone's favorite boxed chocolate fillings.

08of 21

Heart Cookies with Almond Glaze

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (8)

What distinguishes these heart-shape sugar cookies from the competition is the sweet almond glaze on top. To coat your cookies in color, give the glaze a pink or red tint with paste food coloring, then decorate them with a colorful sprinkle mix that includes sugar pearls, jimmies, and nonpareils.

09of 21

Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Pies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (9)

Valentine's Day is all about celebrating perfect pairs, and we think chocolate and peanut butter just might be the ultimate match. This V-Day, mix up a batch of adorable mini chocolate pies, topped with creamy peanut butter filling. Use a piping bag to squeeze melted chocolate onto waxed paper to create the heart-shape accents before serving.

10of 21

Valentine Lollipops

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (10)

You could just hand out store-bought heart lollipops. But we think it's way more festive to make your own with melted Jolly Ranchers; personalize your pops with colorful decorations, like candy hearts or sprinkles. Lollipop-making isn't as complicated as you might think: To make the mold, you'll just need a heart-shape cookie cutter and aluminum foil with lollipop sticks in the middle.

11of 21

Jelly Donut Cake

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (11)

Thick, luscious cream joins a jelly filling—strawberry or cherry, your choice—in this heart-shape donut-style cake. To tempt your loved ones to cut into it ASAP, spread more jelly on top in a heart pattern, then dust with powdered sugar.

12of 21

Valentine's Day Cake

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (12)

We'll always have a place in our heart for classic Valentine's cookies. But we're more than willing to make room for a more glamorous V-Day treat, too. This delicious sprinkle-topped confection would take the cake on its own—decorated cookies make it even more irrestistible. Try this over-the-top dessert for your next Galentine's Day celebration.

13of 21

Grapefruit and White Chocolate Cookies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (13)

A sweet layer of white chocolate perfectly balances the tanginess of these grapefruit cookies. Use a heart cookie cutter to shape the dough, then after baking, dip each cookie in melted white chocolate and top with pink sprinkles for a colorful (and easy!) treat.

14of 21

Heart-Shape Reindeer Sugar Cookies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (14)

Why save your heart-shape cookie cutter for February? Bring it out at Christmastime to create these adorable reindeer cookies with candy eyes and noses. Look closely, and you'll see that the antlers are made of teeny-tiny heart cookies, too.

15of 21

Jam-Filled Hand Pies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (15)

Surprise your crew with these mini hand pies as a Valentine's Day breakfast—then serve the leftovers as dessert later! Fill them with strawberry jam for a burst of festive red, or use chocolate hazelnut spread to add extra sweetness to the middle. Hint: Brush the tops of the pastries with milk before baking to ensure they come out golden brown.

14 Sweet and Savory Hand Pie Recipes for When You Don't Want to Share

16of 21

Chocolate Pistachio Heart Cookies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (16)

A quick dip in melted chocolate and a sprinkle of pistachios takes these heart cookies from simple to off-the-charts delicious in a few seconds. Chopped pistachios are also baked into each chocolatey cookie for a double-dose of rich, nutty flavor.

17of 21

Oaty Doodle Hearts

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (17)

If you need a reprieve from super-sugary treats, turn to this healthier-than-usual recipe: These cookies contain rolled oats and whole-wheat flour, along with a hearty dose of cinnamon. The cookies form easily with your hands, so you can make heart-shape sweets even if you don't have the right cookie cutter.

18of 21

Layered Brownie Heart Dessert

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (18)

Borrow the signature flavors of chocolate-covered strawberries for this indulgent Valentine's Day cake. Homemade strawberry whipped cream and sliced fresh strawberries serve as both the filling and topping for a rich brownie sandwich that'll have you reaching for seconds.

19of 21

Red Hot Sugar Cookies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (19)

Yes, these sugar cookies are sweet, but they're also red hot! Topping your heart-shape cookies with red cinnamon candies sets them apart from their sweeter cousins—and gives your Valentine's Day a spicy kick.

20of 21

Raspberry Swirl Brownies

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (20)

A swirl of homemade raspberry puree injects these rich dark chocolate brownies with fruity flavor. While no one will complain if you cut them into squares, we love the extra-special feel of heart-shape treats. Use any scraps to create layered brownie trifles.

21of 21

Strawberry Cheesecake Bites

View Recipe

21 Heart-Shape Treats to Make Your Valentine's Day Extra Sweet (21)

To make this Valentine's Day dessert, decorate squares of vanilla cheesecake with slices of strawberries that have been cut into a heart shape. A drizzle of honey is the perfect topping.