How to Make a Gluten-Free Sourdough Starter from Scratch (2024)

Last Updated on June 6, 2023

Do you dream of baking loaves of fresh homemade sourdough bread… but can’t eat gluten? I’m here to tell you that dreams can come true! Get started on your gluten-free sourdough journey by following these easy step-by-step instructions on how to make your own gluten-free sourdough starter from scratch – using only three ingredients! Keep in mind that the process does take about a week, but is well worth the wait. At the end, you’ll have a living and active homemade gluten-free sourdough starter, ready to use in any gluten-free sourdough recipe you desire.

Before we dive into the process, let’s go over a few fun facts and frequently asked questions. Then at the end of the article, you can tune into a video demonstration if you please! The video shows the process of making our wheat sourdough starter, but the process is essentially the same.

What is Sourdough?

Did you know that homemade “sourdough” isn’t necessarily sour in flavor? Unlike store-bought or quintessential San Francisco sourdough, most homemade sourdough is usually not very sour at all! It is simply called sourdough because of the process it is made – through natural fermentation.

Rather than adding commercial dry yeast, artisan and homemade sourdough bread rely on a sourdough starter culture to provide loftiness and rise. And that is exactly what we’re going to create today! If allowed to ferment for a very long time, your sourdough can become more sour-tasting if that is what you desire.

Why Make Sourdough at Home?

Because it is fun! Duh.

Also, there are many health benefits of making homemade sourdough bread. The fermentation process helps our bodies maximize nutrient absorption, and also makes the bread easier to digest. So much so, that many people with gluten sensitivities can tolerate homemade (gluten) sourdough with no issues!* I am one of those people. I regularly eat home-baked sourdough made with wheat flour, but cannot stomach other “normal” bread without extreme bloating and discomfort.

*Note: I do not encourage those with celiac disease or extreme gluten allergies to try wheat-based sourdough bread. Yet, if you only have mild sensitivities like myself, you may be interested in trying our classic sourdough starter tutorial and simple sourdough bread recipe. I personally prefer them to gluten-free options, but do what is best for you.

Additionally, homemade sourdough is far less processed than store-bought bread. Especially gluten-free bread, which usually contains a long list of additives. By making your own gluten-free sourdough starter and bread, you have ultimate control over the quality and choice of ingredients.

What is a Sourdough Starter Exactly?

A sourdough starter culture is a living thing. The right combination of water, flour, and warmth creates the perfect environment for yeast and beneficial bacteria (lactobacillus) to live and grow. You’ll see that this gluten-free sourdough starter recipe also calls for one organic apple, which helps inoculate the mixture with beneficial bacteria and wild yeasts. Once established, the colony of yeast and bacteria need to be nurtured with routine “feedings” to keep them alive.

As the yeast and bacteria feed on fresh flour, they convert sugars and starches into acetic acid (which is what makes sourdough slightly sour, healthier, and easier to digest) and also produce carbon dioxide gas. Inside a container, a happily-fed sourdough starter will create air bubbles and grow in size. Then when an active starter is added to the dough of sourdough bread, the starter culture continues to feed and ferment the dough – adding air pockets and rise.

Gluten-Free Sourdough Flour Options

When it comes to baking gluten-free sourdough bread, there are dozens of GF flour types to choose from! Millet, potato, rice, buckwheat, tapioca, sorghum… the list goes on. Most gluten-free sourdough bread recipes call for a combination of several types of GF flours, along with the addition of psyllium husk and/or xanthan gum to help everything bind well in the absence of gluten.

On the other hand, we’re going to keep it really simple for the starter portion! To make a gluten-free sourdough starter, we have found it is best to simply use brown rice flour or buckwheat flour. Or, you can do half and half if you wish! The flavor of buckwheat flour is definitely more pronounced than mild brown rice. We used brown rice for this tutorial.

Another option is white rice flour. However, whole-grain brown rice flour and buckwheat are more nutritious and wholesome than white rice flour. Once your gluten-free sourdough starter is established, you can play with feeding it a variety of these flours, or even sweet rice flour. Sweet rice flour is less gritty and more sticky than other rice flour, which can help act as a binding agent. Feel free to give any combination of those flours a try, using the same process you’ll learn below!

Finally, I do not suggest using an all-purpose 1-1 GF flour for this recipe. We tried to make a gluten-free sourdough starter with a 1-1 replacement flour recently. It technically worked – it rose and got active – but the smell was gnarly! I think all the extra additives in 1-1 flour made something “off”, because it smelled like fermenting vomit.

And now, on with the show!

GLUTEN-FREE SOURDOUGH STARTER INGREDIENTS & SUPPLIES

• Brown rice flour or buckwheat flour (or a combo of both). It is best to use organic if possible. Throughout the entire process of making your gluten-free sourdough starter, you’ll use about 750 grams of flour (1.7 pounds) – so keep that in mind when you’re choosing a bag of flour. We like the organic brown rice flour from Arrowhead Mills. This 6-pack of 24-ounce bags on Amazon is a great deal. It will keep your sourdough starter happy and fed for many months! Our sourdough bread recipe (see the recipe for a rustic GF sourdough boule loaf here) also uses a good amount of brown rice flour, so you can use it there as well.
• One organic apple. Yes, it is essential to get organic! Non-organic produce may not only lack desirable good bacteria, but may have harmful additives that will ruin your starter. We always use a Fuji, Pink Lady, or Gala apple.
• Un-chlorinated or filtered water. Avoiding chlorinated water is important when it comes to any fermentation process, including making sourdough. We use filtered water. A basic carbon filter is enough to remove most of the chlorine from city tap water. In a pinch, bottled water could be used – though I am not a fan of bottled water for environmental reasons.
• A large air-tight glass container. We use this 2-liter flip-top container (about a half-gallon). Using too small of a container will limit the space your starter has to rise. The container should be large enough to allow for the flour/water mixture inside to double in size.
• A kitchen scale. The sourdough world is riddled with recipes that call for flour by weight (including this one), rather than traditional cup measurements. This is because all flours have slightly different weights. For example, this recipe calls for 500 grams of flour to start. 500 grams of Arrowhead Mills brown rice flour equates to 3.25 cups, yet 500 grams of their buckwheat requires a full 4 cups!
• A mixing bowl
• Liquid measuring cup
• A moderately warm location
• Recommended: an ambient thermometer or sticky strip thermometer

INSTRUCTIONS TO MAKE GLUTEN-FREE SOURDOUGH STARTER

Step 1: Mix Flour, Water, and Grated Apple (Day One)

In a large clean mixing bowl, combine 500 grams of brown rice or buckwheat flour, one grated organic apple, and 360 mL of lukewarm filtered water (about 1.5 cups). Mix thoroughly. The texture should be like thick sloppy dough. Not dry and crumbly, but not soupy wet.

Quick tips:

• When you weigh your flour in a bowl, don’t forget to either tare the scale or subtract the weight of the bowl!
• Wash the apple with water before grating it, but do not use soap or other vegetable wash. We grate the apple with a box-style cheese grater. Add the apple skins along with the flesh, but avoid the core and stem.
• If your water is really cold, either allow it to sit out and come to room temperature, or stick it in the microwave (in a glass measuring cup) for 15-30 seconds. Cold water will slow the growth of the beneficial microbes.
• Throughout this process, if your starter ever seems too dry or far too wet, feel free to add a splash more water or flour until the desired consistency is reached as described. The amounts I am providing are a general guide. Again, different flour types and brands will have slightly varying weights.

Once the apple, flour, and water are thoroughly combined, transfer the mixture into a large glass fermentation vessel.The vessel should be clean. I suggest washing it with hot water and vinegar, but avoid using old sponges and/or soap. Mash down the wet dough to remove any air pockets. If possible, try to avoid getting gunk all over the sides of your container. That stuff may be more likely to mold. Use a silicone spatula to clean up the sides if needed. No need to be perfect however.

Now, either wrap a large rubber band around the container or use a glass pen to mark the level of the mixture on the side of the container. This provides a starting point and allows you to easily monitor your starters’ growth.

Finally, tuck the container in a moderately warm location and let it sit for 72 HOURS. The ideal fermentation temperature is around 70-75°F, or 23 degrees Celsius. Colder temperatures reduce beneficial bacteria growth and also increase the chances of mold.

Ways to keep your sourdough starter warm:

If you’re making a gluten-free sourdough starter during the summertime, you’ll likely have no issue keeping it happy by simply leaving the starter out on the countertop. However, if you attempt to create a starter during the winter (or if your house is otherwise on the cool side) it can be a bit more tricky. If you aren’t exactly sure what the ambient temperature is within microclimates in your house (e.g. in particular rooms, on the counter, etc) it is best to use a thermometer to assess the exact temperature where your starter is stored.

A couple options to provide warmth to a sourdough starter are to keep it near a warm appliance, use an electric heating pad or seedling heat mat nearby, or to wrap the container in classic holiday lights. I emphasize classic lights because newer LED lights do not get warm. These are all tricks we use and suggest for keeping homemade kombucha warm and active too!

Last but not least, our favorite easy way to keep both sourdough starter and the proofing dough warm is to keep it inside the oven – with the oven OFF, but oven light on! It creates the perfect cozy home. It if gets too warm in the oven, keep the door cracked open slightly.

Step 2: First Discard & Feed (Day Four)

During the last three days, your starter should have started to get active, bubbly, and rise. It may have even risen and then fell back down again. That’s okay, but means it is getting hungry! The starter will also start to smell a little funky, malty, and semi-sweet – reminiscent of apple cider vinegar.

After 72 hours (about three full days later, but it doesn’t need to be exact) it is time to feed your starter for the first time. The process of feeding a sourdough starter involves first discarding a portion of it, and then adding fresh flour and water. So, any time you hear a reference to “feed” the starter, keep in mind that also means removing some and not simply adding to it.

Feeding the Starter:

• First, open the lid and stir the starter with a clean utensil. This will knock out the air and bring it back down to its original volume.
• Next, remove and discard about half of the volume of starter in the container. I usually just eyeball it, using the mark or rubber band line on the container as a guide. Discarded sourdough starter can be composted, fed to chickens, or used to make other sourdough goodies – like gluten-free sourdough crackers with herbs and cheese!
• Now add an additional 250 grams of fresh brown rice or buckwheat flour and about 180 mL (about 3/4 cup) of lukewarm water to the mix. Stir thoroughly to combine. We simply add them to the starter container and mix it all up. If your container is tall or difficult to stir in, you can also do this in a separate bowl and then put it back into the container. It should be a slightly thinner consistency than the original mix.
• Clean up the sides of the container as needed so you can monitor the rise again (and possible fall).

Now, put the container back into a warm location and let it sit for 48 HOURS this time.

Troubleshooting notes:

If your starter did not rise at all during these 48 hours, allow it to sit for another day before moving on to the next step. Yet if it rose and fell back down (look for smears on the container) then it is time to feed again. If it is acting particularly lethargic, try feeding with half brown rice flour and half buckwheat.

Keep in mind that it is common for the first bout of activity to be more vigorous and obvious than the following few. That is because different short-lived bacteria quickly ferment the starter at first. Yet these are not the same type of bacteria and yeast we desire long-term in our starter, who are slower to develop.

Step 3: Discard & Feed Again (Day Six)

This step is easy! Simply repeat the same discard and feed process that you did previously. Stir it first, discard half, and add more fresh flour and water like we did in the previous step. Yet this time you want to make it a splash more wet than before – like a wet, sloppy dough. Use 250 grams of flour and about 220 mL (just under a cup) of lukewarm water this time.

Now, let your almost-ready gluten-free sourdough starter sit for 24 HOURS If all goes well, it should rise and fall within this time period. The apples should be pretty much be disintegrated by now too.

Step 4: Is It Ready? (Day Seven)

The day has come! If your starter has gone through the phases of rising and falling after each feed, you now have a bonafide active gluten-free sourdough starter on your hands! She is ready for baking. But first, you better give your new friend a name. In fact, it is considered bad luck to not name your sourdough starter!

So… What do I do with it now?

Well, you bake with it! Try our rustic gluten-free sourdough boule loaf recipe here. Another couple awesome options are to make gluten-free sourdough crackers (we love ours with fresh herbs!), or to make fry bread. One of my intsa-friends turned me on to this: heat a non-stick skillet on the stove, add a cooking oil of choice (she uses coconut oil) and then pour in a few big scoops of plain sourdough starter – like pancakes! Spread it fairly thin, allow to cook on each side for several minutes and continue flipping it as needed until cooked through. She likes to serve it with eggs and sausage, but I think the options are pretty endless there!

Ongoing Storage & Care

Your new starter needs ongoing care, but thankfully not as intensive as when you are first getting it established. We find it most simple to store our starter in the refrigerator (which makes it go semi-dormant) and pull it out just on weekends to feed and/or bake with.

To help you learn how to take care of your starter, I put together this guide all about ongoing sourdough starter care. I originally wrote it for classic wheat sourdough starter, but edited it to include special notes for gluten-free sourdough starters as well! The process is essentially the same.

That article covers:

• How to routinely feed your sourdough starter – which is a little different than the feeding process we did here to create it.
• How frequently to feed your sourdough starter.
• Where to store your starter: in the refrigerator or at room temperature?
• How to “ready” your sourdough starter for baking, and more!

FAQ: What is that dark liquid on the top of my sourdough starter?

When the yeast in a sourdough starter has eaten up all of its available food and is hungry for more, it produces a thin dark layer of liquid on top. This is an indication that your starter is more active than you’re feeding it. It is a naturally-occurring alcohol created by the yeast, called hooch. This is totally normal! Do not freak out.

If your starter does develop hooch, you can either pour it off the top or simply mix it back in, then discard and feed as usual. Ours almost always has a thin layer of hooch developed when we take it out of the fridge for our weekly baking.

However, I have noticed that water has a tendency to separate out from brown rice flour even more readily than wheat flour. For example, sometimes a thin layer of water appears immediately after feeding the gluten-free sourdough starter. That isn’t hooch… That is just water, and you can leave it be.

And that is how you make a gluten-free sourdough starter.

So, how’d it go? I hope this article got you one step closer to making all your sourdough dreams come true. Please feel free to ask questions, leave a review, share this article, or just say hi. Thanks for tuning in, and happy baking!